Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Poor Susan

After reading Wordsworth's "Poor Susan", I see correlation between the theme of this poem and with that of Charlotte Smith's sonnets. Both seem to emphasize the point that Nature can only remove us from our daily lives for only a brief moment. Though that moment is enjoyable, we must return back to our lives in human society. I also wanted to point out how Wordsworth seems to compare God and Heaven with beautiful natural surroundings in this piece. For example:

"And a single small cottage, a next like Jove's,
The only one dwelling on earth that she loves."

and

"She looks, and her heart is in Heaven, but they fade,
The mist and the river, the hill and the shade;
The stream will no flow, and the hill will not rise,
And the colours have all pass'd away from her eyes.

Poor Outcast!--to receive thee once more
The house of thy Father will open its door,..."

These analogies do contrast with Smith's pieces, however, who seemed to take a darker turn with her sonnets, which were probably more realistic to human life, but definitely more depressing.


1 comment:

  1. "Nature can only remove us from our daily lives for only a brief moment. Though that moment is enjoyable, we must return back to our lives in human society." These sentences embody an essential message from the poets. However, they make me wonder as to what the purpose of conveying such a message is? Is it more along the lines of what WW wishes to instill in his readers, and to think passively over the absence of nature? Is it more like Smith in wanting to point out that the day to day environment of human society is depressingly more drab than the natural? Or do the poets wish to elicit an active response from readers, one that pushes for a society that incorporates nature in its daily life?

    ReplyDelete